Jennifer's story resonates with me because it contains many of the same elements of my story. I too, grew up in a home where Quiverfull and Christian patriarchy were practiced.
I grew up in a home where the only option that was given me was to get married and have lots of children.
I was taught that not only was this the highest calling a woman has, but the only calling. My only option in life was to first serve my parents at home while I was single, then after I was married, to serve my husband and have lots of children.
Education was seen as something that gave women independence and could lead to them living on their own, not having to rely on their fathers and husbands, and could take them out of the home and away from their job of serving children and husband.
Often Quiverfull/Patriarchal families will isolate themselves and their children and only associate with other like-minded families. Homeschooling is usually seen as the only God-approved way to educate their children, and often times the education is substandard. The mother is often stretched thin because she is constantly pregnant or taking care of a new baby. The older daughters are recruited to take over many of the mothering and household responsibilities leaving little time for study or recreation. Often times little value is placed on education, especially for the girls, because after all -a daughter's job is to be a keeper of the home and a mother. Somehow, in some of their minds, this conflicts with getting a good education.
Another thing that is often stressed in these families is obedience to the father, especially for daughters, even after the daughter reaches adulthood. Single women are supposed to remain under the protection of their fathers. They are often taught that if they stray from this protection, they risk eternal damnation in hell.
Because of all this--the fear, the isolation, the poor education, lack of work experience, and for some, even lack of a social security number and birth certificate--it can be very difficult to leave.
I did have a birth certificate, but other than that, all of the above reasons making it difficult to leave my parents' home, applied to me.
It was the hardest thing I have done in my life, but I did take that big leap of faith and walked away from my parents' home 13 years ago. I could not have done it by myself. It was by the grace of God and the people in my path who helped me. The most important of these was a Franciscan friar who didn't know me or my family but was able to hear the desperation in my heart, that day I sat down and talked to him--(I actually ended up doing way more crying than taking--and for those of you who know me--you know I don't normally just sit down and cry in front of a total stranger).
At the time, I had no understanding of what was really wrong--I just knew my life was unbearable--it wasn't until several years after I left that I discovered that what I experienced is quite common among women who grew up in similar families--and that there are names for the things my parents believed and practiced.
I applaud Jennifer's goal of starting a house to help young women who grew up in similar circumstances. It is very difficult to leave, but having a place to come where there is support and understanding would go a long way to make the transition so much easier for women who are leaving this very specific type of abusive situation.
So please click the link, and vote for Jennifer's essay, and help her make this goal a reality! Then, please share her essay on twitter and Facebook and encourage other to vote for her.
********
Jennifer blogs at Out of the Chrysalis.
If you are interested in learning more about Quiverfull/Christian Patriarchy and the harm it does, especially to the young women who grow up in this movement, I recommend these two books:
Quivering Daughters by Hillary McFarland is written from a Christian point of view, and the author also has an excellent website for young women leaving the this system.
Quiverfull: Inside the Christian Patriarchy Movement by Kathryn Joyce is written from a secular point of view.
thanks for getting the word out about my sister's essay! it's so encouraging to have support from people who know exactly what we've been through.
ReplyDeleteBethany, you are very welcome. I wish you and your sister the very best!
DeleteYou both sound like brave women. I can't imagine such an upbringing.
ReplyDeleteI grew up in it, and 13 years later, I am stunned by this belief system. If I hadn't grown up this way, I think I would wonder if stories like ours are really true.
DeleteI grew up Quaker in a sheltered environment where there was no television, no dancing and father's word was law. I cannot remember any encouragement from him, ever but later I learned that he had suffered much the same. The inability to love or nurture seems to have been like a disability he and his father had and perhaps his father's father and so forth...Breaking the cycle takes courage.
ReplyDeleteYou are so right in that the inability to love and nurture can be passed down from parents to children in a viscous cycle. It takes strength and courage to break away from it, which it sounds like you have done.
DeleteI think what motivates a lot of Quiverfull families though is fear, and often the parents are over reacting to what they perceive as a bad situation in the world, and embrace the belief system with good intentions, thinking that it one of the ways to build a strong family. Unfortunately, this way of thinking often ends up destroying the family, especially if the parents are inflexible when it comes to the core beliefs.
Hi there - this is a brave and thoughtful post. I just wish the people would come to understand that children are just children. Not Christian children, Muslin children or whatever - they may be the children of Christians or Muslins but religion should be choice not an imposition. I know its a naive wish, but you never know what may happen one day!
ReplyDeleteStewart M - Australia
Thank you, Stewart!
DeleteThanks for the link Kateri. I wish her well and hope she gets to realize her dream!
ReplyDeleteThanks, Candy!
DeleteHi Kateri, I found your post very touching. I grew up in a large, loving Mennonite family, but I could relate to so much. We had a car; it had to be black, but we had no radio, TV, musical instruments or contact with the outside world other than neighbors or business. We went to a parochial school until gr. 8 and then we stayed home to help or went to help out other families. My first 'outside' job was when I worked in a bakery at a local grocery store at 18. (I worked there for 8 years.)They had a BARREL of laughs at this little naive Mennonite girl, and I laughed back:):) I have been a stay at home mom for twenty years and sudden;y I find myself on a threshold of 'what next? (school, maybe?)Thank-you for sharing and I am heading over to check out the story.
ReplyDeletesorry, I did neglect to mention that my husband and I left the Mennonites when it came time to raise our own family.(19 yrs. ago) We were visited by the elders and basically told that if we do not intend to support the rules laid out by the church it would be better to leave and not be a stumbling block to others, We were also warned that just because we leave does not suddenly make the wrong, right! It is a very powerful fear they instill. I still battle the grief of hurting my family, but we are not shunned and we do try to respect them and be considerate of them. Thank-you again for bravely sharing...and also for the comment on my blog.
ReplyDeleteKateri, i jumped over tonight to let you know of a meeting of hearts that you might like to get in on. It's hosted by my friend Shelly at Redemption's Beauty. We are meeting and discussing a book called "Leaving Church" by Barbara Brown Taylor once a week on Thursdays. We meet on a private facebook page and just pour out our hearts about our faith journeys. It has been so real and so rich. I felt like you and I connected b/c of the spiritual abuse we have both suffered. Wanted to extend an invitation, just you know you are welcome, friend. (Please don't feel pressured. I had you on my heart and thought I'd reach out a hand.)
ReplyDelete