Showing posts with label Daughter of Patriarchy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Daughter of Patriarchy. Show all posts

Sunday, November 18, 2012

Deceived



Love is an action, not a feeling you say
love is doing, not words you say
so why is it that your actions hurt deep
why is it that I feel pushed away and abandoned
why is it that I work so hard and feel so empty
oh, that's right love isn't a feeling
what I feel doesn't matter to you
what I do is all you care about
"I love you" is just a meaningless set of words
because you say words without actions
are meaningless and affection isn't 
even in your vocabulary--

and yet, 
how am I to know 
that you love me
if you never say it, 
if you never express it 
with feelings?

actions without affection, doing without expressing, 
leaves me feeling rock cold and empty
like pebbles scattered and trampled in the dust--

yet how I feel
will never matter
love isn't about feelings
for after all the heart 
is deceitful and feelings lie
that's all you need 
to remember--
love is an action 
not a feeling

(in spite of you I discovered love
and it is complex, a mix of feelings
and actions, but also much more--
for love-- like life-- cannot be squished into 
a neat little box that can be contained
for if it is controlled, it dies--
see it there, stone cold, lying in the dust.)



Monday, November 12, 2012

Out of Quiverfull

Please click this link and vote for this young woman's essay to help her get a college scholarship and enable her to help other young women.

Jennifer's story resonates with me because it contains many of the same elements of my story. I too, grew up in a home where Quiverfull and Christian patriarchy were practiced. 

I grew up in a home where the only option that was given me was to get married and have lots of children. 

I was taught that not only was this the highest calling a woman has, but the only calling. My only option in life was to first serve my parents at home while I was single, then after I was married, to serve my husband and have lots of children. 

Education was seen as something that gave women independence  and could lead to them living on their own, not having to rely on their fathers and husbands, and could take them out of the home and away from their job of serving children and husband. 

Often Quiverfull/Patriarchal families will isolate themselves and their children and only associate with other like-minded families. Homeschooling is usually seen as the only God-approved way to educate their children, and often times the education is substandard. The mother is often stretched thin because she is constantly pregnant or taking care of a new baby. The older daughters are recruited to take over many of the mothering and household responsibilities leaving little time for study or recreation. Often times little value is placed on education, especially for the girls, because after all -a daughter's job is to be a keeper of the home and a mother. Somehow, in some of their minds, this conflicts with getting a good education. 

Another thing that is often stressed in these families is obedience to the father, especially for daughters, even after the daughter reaches adulthood. Single women are supposed to remain under the protection of their fathers. They are often taught that if they stray from this protection, they risk eternal damnation in hell. 

Because of all this--the fear, the isolation, the poor education, lack of work experience, and for some, even lack of a social security number and birth certificate--it can be very difficult to leave. 

I did have a birth certificate, but other than that, all of the above reasons making it difficult to leave my parents' home, applied to me. 

It was the hardest thing I have done in my life, but I did take that big leap of faith and walked away from my parents' home 13 years ago. I could not have done it by myself. It was by the grace of God and the people in my path who helped me. The most important of these was a Franciscan friar who didn't know me or my family but was able to hear the desperation in my heart, that day I sat down and talked to him--(I actually ended up doing way more crying than taking--and for those of you who know me--you know I don't normally just sit down and cry in front of a total stranger).

At the time, I had no understanding of what was really wrong--I just knew my life was unbearable--it wasn't until several years after I left that I discovered that what I experienced  is quite common among women who grew up in similar families--and that there are names for the things my parents believed and practiced.

I applaud Jennifer's goal of starting a house to help young women who grew up in similar circumstances. It is very difficult to leave, but having a place to come where there is support and understanding would go a long way to make the transition so much easier for women who are leaving this very specific type of abusive situation.

So please click the link, and vote for Jennifer's essay, and help her make this goal a reality! Then, please share her essay on twitter and Facebook and encourage other to vote for her.


********
Jennifer blogs at Out of the Chrysalis. 

If you are interested in learning more about Quiverfull/Christian Patriarchy and the harm it does, especially to the young women who grow up in this movement, I recommend these two books:

Quivering  Daughters by Hillary McFarland is written from a Christian point of view, and the author also has an excellent website for young women leaving the this system.

Quiverfull: Inside the Christian Patriarchy Movement by Kathryn Joyce is written from a secular point of view.


Wednesday, October 31, 2012

Thoughts on the Bible (and a Thank you to Rachel Held Evans)

In the family I grew up in the Bible was the end of the discussion. 

If something I wanted conflicted with what my parents wanted, the big family bible was brought out and opened up and I would be shown that I was clearly wrong and my parents were clearly right.

The bible is God's word and God's word cannot be wrong. Daughters are supposed to obey their parents because that is what God's word says. So why are we even having this discussion in the first place? 

And that was the end of the discussion. 

The bible was presented as a book of rules, a bunch of commandments that had to be followed in order to live a good life. Rather than being a life giving book, it became a book that weighed me down like a ton of bricks, that boxed me and forced me to be someone who I wasn't. It also boxed God in, and did not allow him to work in my life. 

When I left my parent's home and their belief system, I also tossed out the bible.

 Ironically I was raised Catholic (my parents liked to say that we were Bible believing Catholics). One of first things I did after leaving home was to read the catechism of the Catholic Church, in which I discovered a lot of things I never learned growing up in what was supposed to be a Catholic home. One of those things that I learned is that the bible was never meant to be the foundation of our faith. As a Catholic and a Christian, Jesus is meant to be the foundation of our faith. 

It was this realization that kept me from rejecting the Christian faith all together. 

The bible is often ambiguous and is full of contradictions. In order to heal from the spiritually abusive environment I was raised in, I had to listen to God in my heart and see him work in the lives of those around me. I had to see people who did not elevate the bible to a place where only God should be elevated, living compassionate, truthful lives. 

I will be honest, I did not read the bible for years after leaving my parents home other than now and then to look  up a bible verse or to occasionally read the story of Jesus's birth and death. It was too painful and did nothing but leave a bad taste in my mouth and make me feel like I was being stuffed back into a box that I did not belong in. 

Today, I know that is what I needed to do to heal. I needed to come to know the God who wrote the bible--but I needed to meet him outside of the bible. I needed to learn that he is bigger than the box that self professed Bible believers want to stuff him into, and that the life he wants for me is bigger than that box. 

It is still difficult for me to read the bible, but when I read it now, I no longer feel like it all has to make sense. I don't feel like I have to live it in its entirety.  Some of it--apparently God approved slavery and genocide for example--will probably never make sense to me and will probably always fill me with horror. But today when I read it, I see God at work with imperfect people, in an imperfect world, much like the world and people that I see today. I do not necessarily see a mandate on how to live my life. 

I have Rachel Held Evans to thank for the fact that I have been able to pick up the bible again. From her writing, I gather that she sees the bible much as I do--a book that in many ways does not make sense. Yet she continues to read the Bible and not only does she read it, she loves it. It points her to Jesus. 

That is what I want for the bible in my own life, I don't want to read the bible for the bible's sake. I have no desire to live a life based on the bible. But I do desire to live a life patterned after Jesus. If the bible can point me to Jesus, that is all I ask of it. 

I love Rachel Held Evans and her writing simply for the fact that she is able to cut through the rhetoric and chains that surround the bible, especially when it comes to "biblical womanhood" and being a "godly woman" and point us directly to Jesus. She writes gently and humbly. Her writing is not flowery or filled with overwrought emotion, it is simple, concrete and clear. When I read her writing, I see Jesus and the life he wants for me as one of his followers. 

(Rachel's newest book, A Year of Biblical Womanhood released yesterday. I haven't read it yet, but ordered my copy today and am very much looking forward to reading it. In honor of her book and in honor of who is she, many bloggers are writing about what Rachel and her writing means to them and linking up here. .My favorite review of her book comes from Suzanne Paul of the Smitten Word--these two sentences in her review sum up what Rachel's writing means to me: "Rachel writes not to fan flames but to loose chains. In exploring her own frustrations with Scripture and Christian culture, Held Evans grows to love the Bible more — and the One who inspired it and sets hearts free." )


Wednesday, September 19, 2012

Inner Voice Whispers



Family--it has the  power to build you up and release you
       or leave you bitter and broken, spirit crushed and fragmented in the dust.



Pain and brokenness--no one escapes it 
   choose to let it mold you into a thing of beauty. 



Submission and annihilation--woman absorbed into man, leaving her in nothingness. The better way is freedom and respect in oneness, mutual trust and partnership.



In the darkness of the night I hold you tight against me
  from brokenness comes wholeness.
  

The choice is between a vast and shriveled nothingness or a wide and terrifying unknown--take that first hesitant step into the unknown and you will  find beauty and peace.  


Evening sky over the Atlantic Ocean. 

Today's poetry prompt over at Real Toads fascinated me. It was to write several two line poems in the spirit of the oral poetry tradition of Afghan women. These short poems read very much like proverbs and I am sure part of the reason this poetry fascinates me is that I grew up in a very restrictive patriarchal home where I was taught that the voices of women did not matter. In a very small way I can relate to these oppressed women. 

To quote from the prompt "Only five out of 100 women in Afghanistan graduate from high school; most are married by the age of 16.  For many, poetry allows them to express themselves. It's the only voice they have, but women writing poetry is seen as shameful and could result in a beating or even death, reason why they have to rely on pen names.
Women write and recite landai, two-line folk poems that can often be humorous, sexy, raging, tragic and  also deal with love, grief,  war, exile and Afghan independence. The success of the poetry form is attributed to it being easy to memorize, which is really important in a culture where women are poorly schooled and forbidden to write or read.
The word landai means “short, poisonous snake” in Pashto. The poems are collective — no single person writes a landai; a woman repeats one, shares one. It is hers and not hers. Although men do recite them, almost all are cast in the voices of women."

Wednesday, September 5, 2012

It Wasn't You.

It wasn't you.
Well, in a way it was,
but on the other hand, it wasn't.

You would have had to be perfect for him.
For all that talk
about "giving a daughter away"
(how I hate that phrase now!)
it wasn't going to happen.
No one, trust me, NO ONE,
would have been good enough.
At least not anyone
I would have cared to be with.
my destiny was to be that spinster daughter
growing gray in the paternal home
forever waiting for that right someone--
who just didn't exist--and never would.

So it wasn't you.

Or rather I should say,
it wouldn't have mattered if your religion
was the same as mine
(that whole religion thing just makes me sad now,
I've learned since then that it doesn't matter)
or if there was no brokenness in your past
it wouldn't have mattered if you lived next door
or a world away.

They all got the same treatment--
No one was good enough for him.

Linked to Real Toads. 

Wednesday, July 11, 2012

Overcoming A Gendered Childhood

Girls don't______.

 You can fill in the blank and I probably wasn't allowed to do it. In the family I grew up in  girls weren't allowed to do much of anything. It was drilled into me that girls don't ride horses. Girls don't cut wood. Girls don't use tools. Girls don't wear pants. Girls don't play sports. Girls don't play chess. Girls don't compete with boys. Girls don't go out alone. Girls don't do heavy work. Girls don't speak in church.  The list goes on and  on with large and small things. (Besides the "boy" things we weren't allowed to do, there were plenty of traditionally "girl" things that we weren't allowed to do as well, because they were either frivolous or immodest--like wearing make up and styling our hair. Even something as simple as putting one's hair up in pony tail was frowned upon.)

Today, as I was driving home from picking up two little boy goats, I was thinking about my childhood and young adulthood and how I OUGHT to know a lot about goats, because I grew up with them--but I don't, because the boys took care of the animals. (I did learn how to milk, both cows and goats, but that is about the extent of my knowledge of either animal.)

The point of all this really was to keep women helpless and force them to rely on men and make the men in our lives feel like they were big and manly for being able to pound in a nail or put a bridle on a horse. Girls and women were to keep house, cook, and garden, and serve the boys and men. It was the way to protect marriage and family. If a woman got too independent she wouldn't need a husband and would go off and get divorced and the world would fall apart (even more so than it was already falling apart).  It was the same reason that I was taught that a woman shouldn't go to college or get a job--those things would make her too independent, she wouldn't need a man to take of her and that would lead to an unhappy marriage and, in the long run, a divorce.

I was able to ditch the mentality that women shouldn't go to college or work pretty easily. I realized quickly after I left my parents' home that it was very important to me that I be able to support myself financially and I refused to get married until I was done with nursing school and had sustainable income. Now I am very thankful that I do have a job that brings in enough income to pay the morgage and other bills. Shortly after we got married, the economy in Michigan tanked, and my husband who is a public works inspector, no longer had year round work. We will never get rich on my income, but at least I know that I can take care of myself and my family with it and the morgage will be paid.

It has been much harder for me to get rid of the mentality that "girls don't use tools, girls don't do hard labor, girls don't  do this and girls don't do that". I'm trying to conquer that mentality. This summer I am making a much more concerted effort than I have in the past. I hate feeling so helpless--especially since that helplessness is so deeply ingrained in me.

Preparing to get these goats have made me realize just how helpless I am. Our property came with a little goat barn, but it hasn't been used in several years and needed to be fixed up. It has a fence around it, but most of the posts were rotted. I realized I didn't have a clue how to do any of the things that needed to be done to fix things. Even though that helpless feeling I am so familiar with wants to paralyze me, I realize these goats are my project, not my husband's.

So with my husband's help, I am learning about things like landscape lumber (the 4x6's make great fence posts), cyclone fencing, air wrenches, lag screws, and electricians pliers. With the help of the Internet, I am learning about how to take care of goats, what they eat, when to castrate, how to prevent urinary stones, and so many more essential and interesting things. 

Unlike my parents, my husband is all for independent women, and honestly, my helplessness has been a source of frustration for him ever since we met. He has tried to teach me things in the past, but I would usually get so frustrated I would end up in tears and give up. He is positively delighted that I am suddenly taking what appears to a real interest in learning how to do something that involves tools. He was even more pleased when I stepped in front of him while he was starting to hook up the generator during the power outage last week and said, "No, you show me how to do it."

I did learn a lot of things from growing up on a homestead that I continue to use. Things like gardening, cooking from scratch, sewing, understanding soil, canning and preserving food, cheese making. The one thing that is a "boy" thing that I did learn a fair amount about was trees. I spent as much time as I could in the woods, partly to get away from a tiny house filled with too many people, and partly because I loved the woods. I spent a lot of time hunting for and collecting wild medicinal herbs and collecting vines for basket making. Somehow I managed to absorb a lot of what my father was teaching my brothers about the forest. I also absorbed a lot about growing fruit trees and pruning them by watching my father take care of his beloved apple trees.

I am  grateful for what I did learn.

 Now it is just a matter of overcoming that learned helplessness and learning the rest of things a farm girl needs to know. Thankfully, I have a husband who can do just about anything when it comes to tools, building, or big machines. He is pretty amazing, and even more so, given that he was a city boy who grew up in Detroit, and never in his wildest dreams imagined he would marry someone who would end up dragging him out to the country where tractors and chickens and goats are all part of life.

(Note--it is common in families where Christian Patriarchy is practiced for there to be definite gender roles, however, I think my parents were even more extreme than most families I am aware of who follow this belief system.)


(And little goat photos coming soon--they are10 weeks old and are half Nigerian Dwarf (dad) and part Boer and Nubian (mom). My computer died in our recent power outage and the laptop I am using while waiting for the verdict on repairs, is difficult to view photos on. I may just wait to post photos until I have my computer back. Or I may not. We will see. :)

Thursday, June 28, 2012

Sometimes we need that first love...

It was a clandestine love affair, that first unlikely love of mine. Somehow it managed to grow, though caught between a twisted Catholic conscience and the crushing prison of Christian patriarchy and legalism. In the end it left me broken, but at the same time it was one of the things that set me free.

To marry him would have meant to walk away from my parents forever, though at the time I was incapable of forming that reality into words or even putting it into a coherent thought.

There are some who are caught in Christian legalism, who say if you love someone deeply--but don't end up marrying him, you have cheated the the person you do marry. If  your first love isn't saved for your spouse you will be incapable of fully loving him.  

In my experience, nothing could be farther from the truth. Sometimes we need that first love with all its glory and all its pain, to make us into the person who we are suppose be. To make us capable of loving even more deeply and more truly. I know that was the case for me.

I don't regret loving him, though I do wish I could have spared him the hurt my lack of courage and emotional immaturity caused. And I am grateful, that against all odds, he loved me. Though 15 years later, and now happily married, it still hurts a little when I think of him.  Sometimes I wish I had had the guts and courage and emotional strength to just walk away with him.

Because ultimately that is what I did anyway.

But  I realize, the simple fact of the matter is, even though my family was broken and dysfunctional, I am not sure I would have ever had the strength to leave, without having first know and then lost the love he had for me. (I am also pretty certain that at the time, I wasn't ready to be a wife to anyone--but that is a essay for another day.) Yes, there were many other things, large and small that pushed me in the direction of leaving my parents' home -- the older I got the tighter the rules got--and life became increasingly unbearable.

I still don't think I would have left though, as my family was the only life I knew--there is safety in familiarity and some comfort in rules--even if they do make up a prison cell. By nature I am shy and reserved. Going out into the big wide world by myself was a scary thought.

It took knowing love and a shattered heart to break the prison walls and to set in motion the events that set me free --and ultimately made me into the person I am today and led me to the man I love today.

Whether it is right or wrong, my first love will always have a part of my heart. If it wasn't for him and for God quietly working in the mess of it all, I wouldn't be who I am or where I am today.


And for that I am grateful.


Linked to imperfect prose.

Friday, May 11, 2012

Identity

Little girl fettered by invisible chains
hedged in on all sides
by a prison laid stone by stone
of false doctrines of men
life decided for her
no room to breathe or be

breaking free into the sunlight
into the wings of the wind
searching, seeking, growing
soul taking root in sacred soil
finding identity not in men
but as one beloved by the Creator


Linking to five minute Friday.

(The prompt today is identity.)

Sunday, April 15, 2012

Thoughts on Marriage

(This is part of my story that I have felt compelled to share, but have hesitated to do so.
My goal is not is criticise or condemn people who are in happy complementarian marriages, but rather to simply show, that there is another way, that is perhaps worth trying, especially if attempting to follow rigid roles is leading to frustration and unhappiness, or even worse, destroying relationships.  My goal is not to give advice on marriage and I do not even feel qualified to do so. If you are struggling in marriage my advice to you would be to talk to a qualified pastor or marriage counselor.
I think even more than that though, I feel compelled to express my gratitude to my God who is full of grace and mercy. I look at my past and my husband's past, and I look at our present and the prayer that fills my heart is, "The LORD has done great things for us; we are glad." (Ps. 126:3)
If you haven't read a bit about how I grew up, I suggest you click here, to get some of the background.)

 I grew up catholic, but in spite of that, the beliefs my parents taught me regarding marriage and family where much closer to the beliefs held by fundamentalist Christians, and promoted by the likes of Vision Forum and Bill Gothard. Basically, God created men to lead, and women to follow and
support the men in their lives. Wives are to be submissive to their husbands and obey them in all things. Daughters are to remain under their fathers' authority until given in marriage. (And if a daughter didn't get married until she was forty, well that was just her hard luck, God still required her to be under her father's authority as long as she was single.)

My parents taught me that a marriage in which the woman did not submit to and obey her husband and the husband did not lead his wife and family, is a marriage doomed to failure. You will end up with an unhappy marriage consisting of a loud and domineering woman and a weak kneed effeminate man. If the woman does not submit and obey, there will be discord and strife.  They believe that following the few verses in the bible that tell wives to obey their husbands and that state the husband is the head of the wife is the key to having a happy Christian marriage and family.

Except it isn't.

 I believe it was my parents' insistence that a wife lay down her will and follow her husband unquestioningly, that ultimately destroyed the family I grew up in. My father had all the say, my mother had none. Some very bad parenting decisions were made, including some that I know my mom was opposed to, but she went along with them--because she felt it was what God required her to do.  As a direct result of this, a tremendous amount of hurt and pain happened, and even 20-30 years later, the damage that was done seems to be irreparable.

In my family, this obedience wasn't just for wives, it also applied to daughters. As the oldest daughter there was a lot of pressure on me to conform and obey and be a good example. Instead of the rules lightening up as I got older, the tighter they got. As I gradually realized that I was doomed to a life of perpetual obedience to my father, I grew more and more depressed. (Not all families that believe in female submission/male headship believe that daughters are required to obey for their fathers as adults, but some do.)

It was only by God's grace that I ended up escaping from that life (and that is a whole different story for some other day).

After I left home I was given a copy of the Catechism of the Catholic Church. I cried as I read the chapters on the creation of man and women and the chapter on family life. God did not intend to create a rigid structure of unbreakable rules that had to be followed in marriage and family at risk of eternal damnation. Women are created in the image of God, in equal dignity and worth to men. Men and women both reflect different aspects of God, who is neither male nor female. Marriage is presented as partnership where husband and wife work together to attain holiness and to meet each others needs, the needs of their family, and the needs of society around them.

While the chapters on the creation of man and woman, marriage and family life, are packed with quotes from scripture, female submission and male leadership are concepts that aren't even mentioned!

My husband's story is quite different, but some of it echos mine.

He grew up on the east side of Detroit, in a big Catholic family with an abusive father. At age 16, he left home--as a high school drop out and a drug addict.

 He was saved by God's grace from that life and in his late teens joined a charismatic nondenominational  Christian community. He married in his early 20's and he and his wife continued to be part of the that community. From the stories I hear from former members of the community, it sounds like in general it was a positive thing, there were also some very negative things about it.

One of those negative things was the insistence that members follow rigid roles in marriage--that wives be obedient and submission, and husbands be the leaders and decision makers.

My husband will be the first to tell you that this model does not work. At least it did not work for them, and he believes that trying to follow this model was a major contributing factor to killing his first marriage (there were other issues as well, but that isn't my story to tell).  He states it puts undue burden on the husband who is then 100% responsible for all decisions--and he gets all the blame when things don't work out right. It puts the wife in a bad place because she has to ignore her God given instincts and intellect and go along with whatever her husband decides, even if she knows or feels it to be wrong.

When my husband I first talked about marriage, he made it clear that he was not going to be the leader and I wasn't going to submit. We were going to make decisions together. If we were to get married, we were going to be equal partners.

So just what does a marriage of equals look like between two Christians?

Really it isn't that complicated. I can sum up our marriage in one sentence--"My job is to take care of my husband and his job is to take care of me."

If you want to get slightly more complicated about it, read Matthew 22:36-40:
Jesus said, “‘Love the Lord your God with all your heart and with all your soul and with all your mind.' This is the first and greatest commandment. And the second is like it: ‘Love your neighbor as yourself.’ All the Law and the Prophets hang on these two commandments.”
This is what our marriage is based on.

My closest neighbor is my spouse. Marriage is about wanting and doing what is best each other, a mutual laying down of one's life for the other. It is about respecting the other, caring about and furthering the goals of the other.

Our marriage isn't about who is in charge, or who makes decisions and who doesn't. It is about love and trust and respect. It is about giving and receiving. It is about being strong, yet vulnerable.

It is about becoming one, while at the same time becoming more the persons God made us to be.

It is about being side by side, about mutual submission, mutual leadership. It is a dance of love and trust and oneness. One is not above the other, and one is not under the the other. It is about taking risks and responsibilities together.

It is about not confining each other to a narrow box of gender roles and expectations. It is about expanding to God's grace and guidance. It is about realizing that God is bigger than either of us, and he is ultimately in charge.

Sarah Bessy who blogs at Emerging Mummy has a poetic and beautiful post that sums up what this kind of marriage looks like far better than I can. To quote just a bit:
"When it comes to the end, we both bear the responsibility for this love affair, for our family, for the work that we are both called to do and the love we are meant to spill out to show the God we know as Love.

You follow when I step out to a new place and I know when to slide into your new turn as a shadow and you lead us both through but usually, it's just us, always us, trusting each other's heart for the other, moving seamlessly, together."
A common question from those who practice male leadership/female submission in marriage is "What happens when you disagree? Someone has to have the final say!"

Our job is to take care of each other. I trust that he has my best interests in mind. He trusts that I have his best interests in mind. We compromise, or we go with what the person who feels strongest about the matter wants. Again it all boils down to "Love your neighbor as yourself."

I am incredibly blessed and loved by my husband. I can truly say that he lays down his life for me as Christ laid down his life for the Church. I am honored by his unconditional love for me. He tells me that he looks at me and sees the ideal woman of Proverbs 31.

It is amazing to me that God can take two people who have pasts full of pain, brokenness and failure, who come from dysfunctional families, bring them together and make them whole by giving them each other. It also amazes me that through God's grace we have a marriage based on trust and love--a marriage that is a safe place to be, that builds each other up, where two can truly become one.

Again my heart echos the words of Psalm 126--"The LORD has done great things for us; we are glad."

Walking down the isle together after giving our lives to each other.
Linked to Imperfect Prose.

Friday, March 2, 2012

Call of the Woodcock

A simple sound--
the spleak spleak of the woodcock
a familiar sound that brings in spring
and with it tumbling emotions, memories

cool soft air through tangled hair
bare feet on newly sprung grass
still too cold, really, for bare feet
wind tugging on on my skirt
stars over the orchard, dampness, darkness
the richness of a spring night--

something about spring that intensifies
feelings of joy and hope
as well as loss and alone-ness
a dozen years have passed
but the sound of the woodcock
brings it all back
the intense ache of so many spring nights--
as the woodcock flies over the apple orchard
under a velvet spring sky.

(With thanks to my friend Diana Dyer, who writes today about hearing her first woodcock here in Michigan on her little farm not 30 miles from my 13 acres. I have not heard or seen a woodcock since leaving my parents' home in upstate NY--but even so, they are still the sound of spring to me.)

For an audio of a woodcock's call, click here.

Linked to Real Toads.

Friday, January 27, 2012

Musings At Rock House

Cavern walls loomed cathedral-like overhead
We stood in silent awe of  the majesty

A young couple, fingers entwined
Voices, laughter echoing across the rocky walls
The world a paradise, made just for them
Fully alive in the beauty of of their surroundings
Alive in the moment and the splendor of the other
Complete awareness of the beauty and the beloved.

A sharp little pain tears at my heart
 Echos in an empty space--
of young life and love lost to Patriarchal tyranny
Anything outside the circle of protection forbidden.

I set aside the camera for a moment
Waiting for the couple to pass from view
And the youthful laughter to fade.

My husband shakes his head
Young people--they just have to make so much noise.

I smile and reach for his hand.
No--they are doing just exactly
What young people are made to do--
Living life, exploring, absorbing each other,
Souls entwining, becoming one with shared experience
And memories made with only thoughts  for the beloved.

You are right, he said, and squeezed my hand.

And again I smile and am full of gratitude
That God can take two broken people with painful pasts,
and make them whole by giving them each other.
Sometimes I wonder how to define ourselves--
Still practically newly weds--me 36, him 62.
Not young, not old,
maybe between the two of us, we are middle aged?
No matter-we are here and now in awe together.


(Written after our visit to Rock House in Hocking Hills State Park in Ohio.)

Linked to Real Toads poetry challenge and Saturday Evening Post hosted by Elizabeth Ester.

Friday, November 11, 2011

Unexpected Love

I had stepped beyond a broken family
Needing healing from a painful past,
Letting time and silence heal a broken heart
Love came quietly and unexpectedly
It was an unlikely match,
He came from a past of hurt and pain
Anger and dysfunction
But an unexpected love for each other
Brought both of us wholeness again

Linked to Five Minute Friday. and Imperfect Prose.

Wednesday, November 2, 2011

Only a Person Who Risks is Free

As a daughter in my parents' home, being female was all about being protected. Protected from the world that wanted to steal my mind and heart away from my parents. Protected from men who apparently think only of raping and kidnapping girls and young women. Protected from having to make my own decisions. Protected from falling in love and ending up in a bad marriage or with a broken heart. Protected from the need to support myself.

Men were supposed to be the protectors, the leaders, the breadwinners. A woman who stayed within the protection of her home and under the authority of her father (and then the husband that he approved for her) was safe and cared for,  both spiritually and physically. Only a rebellious woman would dream of stepping outside of those boundaries.

For someone who is shy like me and a bit hesitate to step beyond herself, there is a certain kind of appeal in a life where there are clear boundaries, in a life where as long as you follow the rules and stay under your God given protector, you can't mess up. In  way, how I grew up, was for me, a risk free life.

Except it wasn't. Because only a person who risks is free.  And the lack of freedom didn't save me from falling in love and ending up with a broken heart. It didn't save me from loosing faith and belief in God. It didn't make me grateful to those who were protecting me. It didn't make me a better person or a better sister. I was stifled, unable to grow emotionally or spiritually. All it got me was a life of despair.

I traded freedom for a risk free life, and in giving up freedom, I took the biggest risk of all--that of not being willing to risk anything. It almost killed my soul, and in the end, it led to me contemplating taking my own life.

The first decision I made on my own, was the scariest one I have ever made.  That decision was to walk away from my parents' safe little world that had all the answers, into the unknown world. It was my first attempt at doing something risky. For me it was a huge step of faith--like stepping over a cliff in the dark and not knowing if something would catch me before I hit the bottom.

I had given up on God when I made that decision to walk away. But the great thing about God is that he is willing to meet you where you are, you just have to step out in faith.  He was there, in the darkness as I stepped over the cliff and he caught me.

I discovered that when I stepped outside of the protection of men, I stepped  into the arms of God and into his protection. In a life lived only under God's protection there are risks and responsibilities. There is no one but yourself to blame for your failures and mistakes. But it is a very worthwhile trade, for under God's protection there is also life, freedom and happiness.

Today I contemplate which direction to turn as turn as my dream job goes away and I face different options for work, and even the possibility of unemployment for the first time in my working life.  However instead of being fearful with these changes and the decisions I must make, I am excited to see where this will go. I am embracing the opportunity for growth and once again stepping beyond myself.  Whatever I end up choosing, there will be risks involved, but I know that God is bigger than me and he knows the big picture. I know he will be there at the end of my decision and in the unknown, waiting for me.

 "The greatest hazard in life is to risk nothing.
The person who risks nothing, does nothing,
has nothing, and is nothing.
They may avoid suffering and sorrow,
but they cannot learn, feel, change, grow, love, live."

--Author Unknown

Linked to Imperfect Prose and Life Unmasked.

Tuesday, October 4, 2011

Alone in the Woods


The woods have always been a lifeline and a refuge for me. Growing up, our little home was surrounded by thousands of acres of woods.  As an introvert  in a very large family in a very small house, I often escaped to the woods to be alone.  Alone in the deep forest I felt free.

Expressing emotions was something that was discouraged in my family, especially if they were negative emotions. When I was angry or upset I would turn to the woods and the maze of logging trails within it for comfort. The music of the wind in the treetops would soothe my soul and alone with the trees, I could cry and be real.

As a teenager I took my hopes and dreams (the few I allowed myself to dream) to the woods. I spent many hours wandering logging trails hoping, praying, dreaming.  

As a young adult, as the poison of patriarchy and unhealthy, stifling family dynamics began to kill my soul, I continued to turn to the woods to find peace and hope and escape from the pain, confusion, and anger that I carefully kept hidden  in my heart.

I fell in love and it was a love of the woods that connected us. It was a marriage, at least with the mindset I had back then, that could never be. I loved him anyway and would sometimes slip away to the woods to feel close to him.

I really wasn't supposed to go wandering in the woods by myself. One of the family rules was that girls should stay within sight of the house unless they had someone with them for safety reasons. It was one of the few rules I broke growing up and I broke it all the time. The forest was my lifeline. By the time I left home at 26 my feet had pretty much memorized all the logging trails in all the woods around us. I could wander them at night without getting lost. (Today that amazes me, because I have the worse sense of direction of just about anyone you have every met. I can get lost driving down my own street in the dark!)

After leaving home, I have always  found woods to wander in.

 I spent a year at Madonna House in Ontario when I first left. Again, one was the rules there, was that guests weren't to go wandering in the woods by themselves. It was the only rule I broke. I will admit I felt a little guilty about it, but I did it anyway. The woods in that part of Ontario were very different from the woods I grew up in, but they had a beauty of their own and I felt at home in them. And again, it was an escape from constantly being with people. (Unlike the woods I grew up in, the woods there did have an actual element of danger--there were both wolves and bears in the woods. I never did see any, but other guests and staff members would occasionally see them.)

As a nursing student in Michigan, I spent a lot of time in the woods behind the college campus. I slipped away there between classes and I often came to school early to do my homework there. I would go there before exams to clear my head and review notes. While it wasn't a large woods, it was a pretty one, with lots of wild flowers, a small stream, and many different kinds of birds. In fact the only other person I would sometimes see there was one of the biology instructors who would go out to the woods to birdwatch.

Living in town was hard for me in that I felt completely out of my element, but the one redeeming factor about the little city I lived in for several years was that there were many parcels of woods set aside as city parks with nothing in them but walking trails. One particularly beautiful woods became my lifeline while I lived there. I walked there almost every day for 9 years.

When we were first dating, my future husband and I spent many hours walking together in that woods. The trails ran through a beautiful woods that in the springtime was a fairyland of native woodland flowers, then down to a river across a foot bridge and through a native prairie meadow. Walking the full several miles of those trails was almost as good as being back in the woods and meadows of upstate NY.

Today, I don't go to the woods to escape. I'm finally in a place in my life where don't have anything to escape from. I find peace and rest and belonging on our little plot of land. I have a job I enjoy. A husband who loves me. The God I know today, is a God of love, not a God of rules.  But I still go to the woods. In addition to the small ones on our 13 acres, we are surrounded by  state land and many nature areas. Today I go to the woods to rejuvenate. With chronic fatigue, and the mental fatigue that goes along with it, there are many days that I feel I can hardly get off the couch. A slow ramble in the woods helps brings me back into balance and restores a bit of energy.

 A day partly spent in the woods, even if I don't get anything else done, is never a day wasted.

Linked to Imperfect Prose.


Wednesday, September 21, 2011

On Freedom

Sometimes I just stop and marvel at the freedom I have.

 I'm talking about the little, seeming insignificant daily  freedoms that most people take for granted.  Things like being able to pull my hair back into a pony tail if I want too. Wearing a shirt that I like. Wearing jeans. Going someplace outside of the house without having to ask permission. Being in control of what I cook and eat. Being able to go places--even places as simple as church or to the store--alone. Deciding what I am going to do for the day. Sleeping all day on the couch if I want to.

Some of the things I marvel at are bigger, but still freedoms that I think most people take for granted. Driving a car, for an example. Going to school. Working at job and earning money. Getting to decide what happens to that money. Marrying someone that I wanted to marry without having to get any one's approval.

I do not take any of these things for granted because for the first 26 years of my life, I did not have any of these freedoms. 

Christian Patriarchy takes freedom away from the its daughters. In every home this looks a bit different. In my case, while I had a fair amount of freedom on our homestead, I was not allowed to leave it without my father or a brother with me (except for a few times when I went to help other large like minded families for a few weeks.)  The one time I expressed an interest in learning something that did not relate to homesteading or eventually being a stay at home wife and mother, I got a two hour lecture on the roles of women. I quickly learned not to express anything of that nature again. Things like clothing and hair where tightly controlled. We were all expected to conform to a family schedule that revolved around work, meals, and prayer. Anything that I wanted to do outside of the family schedule I had to get specific permission for, and often that permission was denied. I never made a decision on my own until I made that decision to just leave.

 I wasn't literally walled in, but for the longest time, it never occurred to me that I could leave. This is hard to explain to someone who has not been raised in a restrictive belief system. I was an adult, legally my parents had no right to run my life and I was legally free to leave, but in my mind, I did not have that freedom.

The reasoning behind all this, in my family, at least, is that girls and young women needed to be protected. Both from themselves and from the evil world and all that is out there that might harm them and tempt them. After all the original sin entered the world when Adam let Eve go wandering off in the garden by herself---this enabled her to talk to a stranger who then talked her into eating the forbidden fruit. The real original sin wasn't Eve's sin of picking and eating the forbidden fruit, it was Adam's sin of not being responsible for and protecting his wife.

And then there are those scripture verses about wives obeying their husbands. In some patriarchal families this gets translated to mean that all women, married or not, needed to be under a man, normally a father or husband, but if you didn't have either of those, the nearest male relative would do. A woman could only be assured she is in God's will if she is obeying the man who has authority over her. Leaving that authority is a sure way of ending up outside of God's will and putting yourself at risk for eternal damnation.

Is it any wonder I felt like I was in prison? The walls weren't physical, but the they were as real as if they had been built of iron and stone.

Even after I left, it took me a while to embrace the freedom that God gives to all His children. Initially I felt a lot of guilt, shame, and fear. I slowly learned that God loves me as I am and for who he made me to be. His desire is that I become that person that he made me to be. I learned that it is okay for me to make my own decisions. I learned that the world is filled with so many good people and so much beauty and that it is not a place to fear.

I have a husband whose idea of protecting me is to make sure I have a cell phone, a credit card, and a can of pepper spray in my purse when I leave the house. And a Triple A card, just in case my Explorer breaks down. (And he checks the oil and airs my tires once a week.) He would never dream of limiting where I go or limiting the decisions I can make. In his care, I feel loved, not imprisoned. I feel like a human being, a beloved child of God, and a treasured wife. I am free, for better or worse, to stand before God and be the person he made me to be, without having to go through another person.

Hardly a day goes by that I don't pause for a moment say a grateful prayer for the freedom I have, both large and small, and both as a human being and as a child of God.


One of my many mystery roses...the sunlight on her petals, the many little outstretched buds, her uplifted petals...all make me think she knows what freedom is...

Tuesday, September 13, 2011

Stormy Night

I wander through the stormy night
as the wind tears at my dress
and the pouring rain runs through my hair
and mixes with hopeless tears

the blackness of the night matches
the darkness in my heart
I am a young woman --an adult
who's heart tells me one thing
and yet my father pulls out the bible
and tells me my heart is wrong

something simple, something good
wanting to be with a sister,
who wants me to be with her
yet this is wrong
 for my father tells me so
and the bible is there to prove it

you grow up being told
that family is the most important thing of all
everything we do is because family
is what really matters
then you grow up and find out
that family isn't so important after all

the only thing that is important
is what your father says and thinks
you struggle against the storm
in your heart because you feel
a combination of love and fear

I want to do what is right
but I feel so helpless
wandering alone in the stormy night
but it is only a reflection of
the silent storm raging in my heart

(if you haven't done so already, read this post to see the perspective this is coming from.)

This post is part of Imperfect Prose.

Thursday, August 18, 2011

Daughter of Patriarchy

Don't fall in love with a daughter of patriarchy.
She is not free,
her heart is not hers to give away.

Secret kisses stolen
in the darkness of the night.
In your arms it felt so right.
Two hearts that ached to be together,
but a universe apart,
two worlds that could not be reconciled.

Don't fall in love, don't fall in love
with a daughter of patriarchy.
She is not free, she is not free.

Though it was too late for you and me,
In the end, it was in part,
your love that set me free.
It was the beginning of chipping away the wall
that held me prisoner and causing it to crack and fall.
Your love is part of who I am.

Don't fall in love with a daughter of patriarchy.
She is not free,
her heart is not hers to give away.

Me at age 24.

I wrote the above poem recently with no intention of sharing it on this blog.

I have been wanting to write a little more about my past, and perhaps occasionally incorporate some of my memories from growing up on a  into my blog posts. It is still hard for me to separate growing up in a Christian patriarchal family (a negative thing) with growing up  living simply (a positive thing.).

Up until recently I didn't talk much about my past. When I left my parents home 11 years ago, I had a strong desire not to be defined by my parents or by the way I grew up anymore. I knew I needed to learn who I was and figure out how to be my own person. For another thing, it literally took me years to make much sense of my growing up years. I grew up "Little House on the Prairie" style complete with long dresses and tiny log cabins. On the surface my big family with lots of brothers and sisters looked serene and perfect. Underneath the surface though there runs the threads of a darker story.

That darker story is that of the spiritual and emotional abuse that comes with adhering rigidly to Christian Patriarchy...a belief system where daughters are only valued for how they relate to the men who have authority over them. A belief system that can lead to deep depression, self hatred, and despair in the wives and daughters who are oppressed by it.

For years I thought I was the only one who felt this way. I blamed the somewhat unique way I grew for the way I felt. When I discovered No Longer Quivering and Quivering Daughters a few years ago, I breathed a deep sigh of relief and realized I was not alone. I could relate in some way to every survivors story and realized that homesteading in and of itself was not the problem.

The past year or so, I have become more comfortable with my past. It is part of what makes me the person who I am today, but I am learning to no longer let it define me. I am learning to embrace the good things that my parents taught me and reject the harmful.
 
I actually had a relatively happy childhood, and it wasn't until I was in my teens and early twenties that the confines of patriarchy begin to suffocate me. The last few years I lived with my family, I felt like I was in a prison I could not escape from. It was difficult and scary for me to walk away from the safety of everything I knew, into a completely foreign world.

 Every daughter of patriarchy has her own story. Homesteading and growing up in a patriarchal family affected each of my siblings in different ways. I would not presume to speak for any of them. Honestly, because of my compliant personality and because I truly did love most of the things about  growing up the way I did, I think I had it easier in a lot of ways than some of my siblings did. I missed out on a lot of the emotional abuse that some of them suffered. Even so it wasn't always easy.


This post is part of Imperfect Prose.